September 1, 2011; David C. Cook
When Gabi and Lia finally learn to surf the river of time, they realize they must make hard choices about life and love in the third and final book in the River of Time series.
Gabi and Lia Betarrini have learned to control their time travel, and they return from medieval Italy to save their father from his tragic death in modern times. But love calls across the centuries, and the girls are determined to return forever—even though they know the Black Plague is advancing across Europe, claiming the lives of one-third of the population. In the suspenseful conclusion of the River of Time series, every decision is about life … and death. (courtesy of Goodreads)
Forgive me, my friends. I'm going to confess a sin. I cannot profess undying love and adoration for Torrent, the final book of the River of Time series. I can happily claim that I enjoyed the book greatly, but I don't share in the belief common among most reviewers that the book is virtually perfect.
Torrent has a lot of things going for it. There is tons of action. The She-Wolves get into as much trouble as ever. Oftentimes, they purposely lead themselves into trouble in a selfless attempt to help the Forelli's. Someone you care about will die, in a rather horrible way. Once again, the violence is not tamped down. You certainly won't be bored reading this book.
And there is no lack of hot medieval guys. Luca remains cute and funny. Marcello becomes more likable. He is every mother's dream for her daughter - brave, steady, romantic, responsible, kind. I liked him more in Torrent than in the previous books. But my heart belongs to Lord Greco. Swoon! Sexy, dangerous, loyal, good.
Gabi is a highlight of this series. She is one of the better written YA heroines. I love her bravery, that she happily steps up to fight for causes she believes in. In Torrent, she faces difficult choices - between what would be easy and pretty good versus what would be hard but better. I admire her determination to not take the easy route when what is right demands something different. I also like that Gabi makes mistakes and does stupid things that make the fight harder. It makes her more realistic and relatable.
Now for the reason my overall feelings for this book are less than perfect. There's too much cheesiness and convenience. I am happy that Gabi was able to reunite her entire family - Mom, Dad, Lia, and her. She clearly cares for all of them deeply. But the big happy family theme with all four people fighting felt forced. Part of me wanted to cheer them on and the other part wanted to roll my eyes. Plus the fact that all family members were good fighters (even Mom's newly acquired skills) seemed overly convenient. Some parts of the plot cleaned up too nicely to be believable (to the extent that a time travel book can be believable). Other parts, such as the origins of the Brotherhood of which Marcello, Lord Greco, and others were a part, were introduced, but never fully explained. Finally, while I like Marcello, I love Lord Greco. In my ideal book, I would love the main guy in the novel more than the foil. But then again, plenty of people are Team Jacob and I don't think that diminishes Twilight. It's just my preference.
I would recommend that anyone read the River of Time series. While I have a few reservations about it, it is certainly fun, action-packed, and oozing with romance.
Oh...I'm going to admit that I didn't read your review! I already know I'm going to read the book soon...so...But I did skim and am disappointed to hear that it didn't quite live up to the first two in the series!ReplyDelete
♥ Melissa @ Melissa's Eclectic Bookshelf
I've heard such great things about this series and I have to pick it up. Sorry that this one ended a little too conveniently for you.ReplyDelete
I haven't read this series but it sounds like something I'd really enjoy. I think I'll have to check it out, despite the too convenient ending. :)ReplyDelete
Sounds like an interesting series, I'll totes have to check it out! Thanks for sharing.ReplyDelete
That convenience theme with Gabi and her family and their abilities rang true since book one, and by the end, I'd gotten used to it and just ignored it at the end, but yes, I understand that frustration, because I was feeling it too. Still, I'm happy they all got their HEA!ReplyDelete
I love this series! It's so awesome! Loved the review :)ReplyDelete
I'm getting the first book as a NOOKbook on my new NOOK at the beginning of next month.ReplyDelete
I'm also not the biggest fan of these books; it drives me crazy that they went back in the past and are probably changing SO much stuff around! I was also bothered by how easy everything came. I'm also a Lord Greco fan :)ReplyDelete
I didn't absolutely love Waterfall either (the only one of the series that I've read so far), for much of the same reasons that you mentioned - like the convenience and cheesiness - but it was definitely fun and fast paced. I'm sure I'll enjoy the other books once I get to them - even if I have to suspend my judgement a little bit.ReplyDelete
Of course you know how much I love this series :) But I also totally agree with what you're saying (I just give it a mental pass. My Special Shelf books aren't perfect books by any means, they're just perfect for me).ReplyDelete
I agree about the convenience. It is unbelievable that they were all awesome fighters, and a tiny little part of me actually wanted their father to die in the end (kind of like a "NO, you CAN'T change everything to make it work out 100% in the end. Some things are set in stone.") But...I also love the warm happy family reunited feeling, so I'm also ok with it.
I also adore really cheesy puns, so I'm pretty much ok at that cheese level (and yes, it's totally cheesy) :P