Release Date: March 24, 2009
Publisher: Margaret K. McElderry Books
To save her mother's life, Clary must travel to the City of Glass, the ancestral home of the Shadowhunters - never mind that entering the city without permission is against the Law, and breaking the Law could mean death. To make things worse, she learns that Jace does not want her there, and Simon has been thrown in prison by the Shadowhunters, who are deeply suspicious of a vampire who can withstand sunlight.
As Clary uncovers more about her family's past, she finds an ally in mysterious Shadowhunter Sebastian. With Valentine mustering the full force of his power to destroy all Shadowhunters forever, their only chance to defeat him is to fight alongside their eternal enemies. But can Downworlders and Shadowhunters put aside their hatred to work together? While Jace realizes exactly how much he's willing to risk for Clary, can she harness her newfound powers to help save the Glass City - whatever the cost? (courtesy of Goodreads.)
City of Glass is a fitting end to the original The Mortal Instruments trilogy. I go back and forth on whether it's my favorite book of the three. It's hard to beat the first book. City of Glass ties everything up nicely. Perhaps too conveniently, but it's nice to have a satisfying ending.... Even if it's just the end of the beginning.
Like City of Ashes, City of Glass is told from multiple points of view. This has a jarring effect, but I like it much better in this book. Maybe because I'm used to it.
Jace is my favorite point of view. Unfortunately, we don't get enough from him. There's lots of him from other people's viewpoints, but he is a much more layered person when I'm inside his head. He puts up a hard front of sarcasm and meanness. We do see his passionate side when he's with Clary, but those moments are few and far between. When we read from his perspective, we see the scared boy behind the hard shell.
I go back and forth on whether I like Clary. She does some really stupid things. Sure it's in the name of saving her mother and then saving others, but I still think there's a subconscious arrogance to it. She's convinced that her way is the only way, damn the consequences. This puts herself and others at danger, as it did when she illegally portaled to Idris and dragged Luke with her. On the other hand, this confidence comes in handy when she needs to persuade people to take advantage of her unique talent for creating runes.
I do like how fully developed the secondary characters are. Simon has gone from being nerdy and desperately reckless to brave and confident, in a somewhat geeky way. Luke is still my favorite character. He comes into his own in this book, establishing himself firmly as Clary's father (in every way but biology) and a quiet strength capable of leading both werewolves and Shadowhunters, if they're willing to listen. Isabelle is hard-edged and b*tchy, but she shows a softer, more loving side with the greater presence of her little brother. Alec works on growing a backbone; more specifically he works on accepting who he is and those who care for him.
The pacing is well done. Even more than the first book, City of Glass has a huge amount of back information. We learn so many details about Idris, about the Shadowhunter political structure, about Valentine, about the origin of Clary and Jace's unusual abilities. It's like the last three Harry Potter books crammed into one. The book could be one massive info dump, but instead we get the background evenly spread out between page-turning action scenes.
The final battle with Valentine was fabulous. I think Ms. Clare created a more layered villain than Voldemort. Unlike Voldemort, Valentine was capable of love. That makes him such a more real person.
*Spoiler: Highlight text to read:
The paragraphs right after Valentine kills Jace gives me chills:
"She saw Valentine sink to the ground and pull Jace onto his lap as if Jace were still very small and could be easily held. He drew him close and rocked him, and he lowered his face and pressed it against Jace's shoulder, and Clary thought for a moment that he might even have been crying, but when he lifted his head, Valentine's eyes were dry. "My son," he whispered. 'My boy.'
...Valentine held Jace and brushed his bloody hair back from his forehead. He held Jace while he died, and when the light went out of his eyes, and then Valentine laid his adopted son's body gently down on the ground... 'Ave-,' he began...but his voice cracked, and he turned abruptly and walked back toward the altar." (p. 488)
Both times I've read this book, it's not Jace's death that shocks me, but the fact that Valentine really did love his son. It makes it all the more heartless that he sacrificed him for the cause. At the same time, his capability to love another person takes him beyond the realm of cardboard villain. (On a picky grammar note, the first paragraph contains an enormous sentence. There are four "and's". It's awkward).
City of Glass puts such a good cap on The Mortal Instruments. As much as I enjoy reading more about Clary and Jace, a large part of me wishes the series had ended here. I felt good at the end - that giddy, happy feeling you get when you slow to the stop at the end of a rollicking roller coaster ride.
Rating: 4 / 5
Here's How to Buy the Book!
Yeah, I would've been happy if this series had terminated here with City of Glass. It really was a good ending! Hopefully the ending of the sixth book will evoke the same kind of happy, satisfied feeling.ReplyDelete
This was definitely my favorite of the first 3. I haven't read any of the books past this because I just loved how it ended. I'm kind of scared to read the next book since I know it will probably make me mad. I know I'll eventually read it though because the not knowing will drive me crazy. Oh man this series! I'm so ready for the movie. :)ReplyDelete
I don't mind a convenient ending, where all the ends are tied up. I do hate too many loose ends or muddled endings, though! So, this was the original end but she wrote more because...she was making good money? The fans demanded it? (I've only read one from this series and one from the series that's set earlier so I don't really know...)ReplyDelete
I loved how SImon was in this book. What great character development!ReplyDelete
I stopped a this book and haven't read all the spinoff series. I felt like it ended in a good place.
Karen @ For What It's Worth
This is one of my fave books. I really love the build up toward the final battle. Lovely review.ReplyDelete
I totally agree with you - if the series had stayed a trilogy I would have liked The Mortal Instruments significantly more. The last book is just...*shudders* Ugh. Gross.ReplyDelete
Its a hard choice but THIS is my favorite book of the series for some reason! Loved you review lol thought you should know! You should come over to my blog @ http://straightfromthereadersmouth.blogspot.com Im new to the blogosphere and would really appreciate follows (:ReplyDelete
It's been so long since I read the first three books, it's hard to really remember much. I mean I remember the general story line, but that's about it. I do remember Clary doing some really stupid things though and Jace was slightly frustrating since he was so closed out to everyone. But even with the things I liked less, I did still enjoy this one too.ReplyDelete
Yeah he was a great villain :) Also this too is where I stopped reading the series too. Loved Simon too :)ReplyDelete
This was a spot on review! I just started the Clockwork Princess and am loving it too!ReplyDelete
Think @ Thinks Books
I totally love this series! Great review.ReplyDelete
My book club read this entire series this year and most in the group said what you are saying... that the series probably should have ended with this book. Good review!ReplyDelete
I actually quite liked the next book, but I'm definitely in the minority there. I think most people agree that the series should have ended here. I'm glad you enjoyed this book though! I do agree about the secondary characters. I definitely warmed to Simon and Isabelle a lot more by this book. Fantastic review. :)ReplyDelete
Back when I read this book there were only 3 books in the series! I remember that part of me wanted more, but overall I thought it was a fitting end to the series. If only I knew what was to come. Ha!ReplyDelete