Monday, April 1, 2013

Manga Mondays #145: Swan vol. 3 by Kyoko Ariyoshi

Manga Mondays Meme

I've been doing Manga Mondays every week since I started my blog almost 3 years ago. It started out as a personal feature, but I decided to turn it into a meme last year. There are quite a few people who do Manga Mondays. I don't claim by any means that I owned or created the idea of Manga Mondays - it's an obvious choice given the alliteration. I think a meme is a great way for everyone to publicize their own Manga Mondays and get a little more publicity.

The linky will be below my review.

Swan vol. 3 by Kyoko Ariyoshi


When three of her talented classmates are chosen for a special performance in Russia, the ballet capital of the world, Hijiri Masumi is included in the group as a backstage crewmember. When opening night arrives, the Russians are pleasantly surprised at the skill of the young Japanese dancers, especially Kyogoku Sayoko. The Russians immediately consider Sayoko for a lead role in their upcoming Bolshoi Ballet performance until stress and fatigue deal a terrible blow to Sayoko and she tears an Achilles tendon! Fate shines on Masumi as she is selected as the substitute dancer. Can she give the performance of her life on this world stage? (courtesy of Goodreads)


*Warning: Potential spoilers. My manga reviews tend to be more of a summary than a review. I find it hard to review manga in the same way I do regular books.

Several volumes into Swan, I think it is a fascinating, but sometimes frustrating manga series. I love the art. Ariyoshi has a fabulous way of showing movement in her drawings, by showing a freeze frame of a dancer at each stage of a leap or jump. I love the detailed backdrops of the dance scenes.

I can't decide whether I like Hijiri Masumi, the main character. Most of the time she is the stereotypical Japanese girl - naive, super-sweet, self-sacrificing, modest to the point of being self-destructive. It's a personality type that still features prominently in modern manga series. At other times, however, she displays an admirable amount of inner strength. She's persistent and reacts positively to criticism by working that much harder. She pushes other people to have faith in themselves even if she doesn't treat herself the same way.

The plot in volume 3 is framed around Sayoko, the star Japanese ballerina. She performs masterfully in front of a skeptical Russian audience and then sustains a horrific injury. Hijiri is named to take Sayoko's place in auditioning for a prominent role in a Russian ballet.

I was pleasantly surprised in the first two volumes that the series was progressing relatively realistically. Hijiri didn't immediately catapult into success. But now, fantasy is setting in. I find it hard to believe that someone who until recently was years behind her peers is now being viewed with respect if not adulation by many skilled professionals. Admittedly, they do acknowledge that Hijiri is technically flawed but I wouldn't think her artistic style could make up for a lack in technique. Still, it's a fun series and I'm eager to continue.

Sign up for the Manga Mondays Meme!


  1. As long as her inner strength continues to grow and be present, I think that, balanced with her more stereotypical characteristics, Hijiri sounds like an interesting character. Plus, again. TRAVEL! Always a win for me.

  2. I would think ballet is not an artistic medium you could bluster you way through - where style would make up for lack of technique just as you said. It seems to me like technique is of vital importance:) Still, as long as I knew I would have to suspend a little disbelief going in, I'd be fine with it!

  3. Sounds like a fun series. Do you think it will turn dark like "Black Swan" or semi-serious yet fun like the movie "Center Stage"?

  4. Interesting. Haven't heard about this manga before, and from the way you described it, it seems just okay.

    Thanks for sharing!

  5. Hello,I love reading through your blog, I wanted to leave a little comment to support you and wish you a good continuation. Wishing you the best of luck for all your blogging efforts. |

  6. Hi, i think that i saw you visited my blog so i came to “return the favor”.I am trying to find things to enhance my website!I suppose its ok to use a few of your ideas!! |

  7. This article gives the light in which we can observe the reality. This is very nice one and gives indepth information. Thanks for this nice article.
    foodspan |


I love comments. I appreciate every one! Thank you in advance.

This blog is now an award free zone. I just don't have time to pass on the awards as they deserve.